Lessons in Pathology
Thursday, January 7th, 2010It must have been our third of fourth time hanging out together. I had been dating this guy for a few weeks, and that evening he had invited me over for dinner to impress me with his favorite “stew”. The stew was good, what wasn’t good was the conversation that ensued from it. While we ate, I told him that I’m generally not a fan of stews except for this Persian stew called Abgoosht that my mom makes. I explained that what made her stew so good was the bone marrow in it. As I continued to vividly describe how succulent and irresistible bone marrow is, I could see a countenance of disgust take over his face. He was a Pathologist and so if anyone, I expected him, of all people, to appreciate the value of bone marrow.
Yeah… not so much. The first words out of his mouth were, “You know what you’re doing is very pathological right?”
“How so?” I asked, “Have you ever heard the expression, you are what you eat?” he replied.
I frowned at him and asked, “So you’re telling me that by eating bone marrow, I’m eating myself?”
He said, “Yes,” to which I condescendingly replied, “Well, at least I taste good.”
Oh, the irony of my attempts for ten minutes to try to explain to this “Pathologist” that bone marrow was highly nutritious and good for the brain. I kept repeating the sentence “It’s a wonderful source of protein and high in monounsaturated fats – the good fats- and it tastes so good.” He shook his head continuously. To him, even as a scientist, eating bone marrow was an act of food extremism, one that he found hard to swallow. I told him he lacked an imagination and had no idea what he was missing out on. My Persian-Armenian girlfriends and I laughed about it later. We concluded that homeboy was clueless and accusing someone of being “pathological” for eating Abgoosht was merely a reflection of his own pathology.
Bone marrow is the perk that comes with eating Abgoosht, a Persian stew whose recipe my mother has conquered. The shanks and the bone marrow marinate slowly for hours enriching the broth while the addition of dried limes, chickpeas, tomatoes, potatoes and savory leaves, brings together a great stew. It’s a flavorful and aromatic stew that’s a perfect way to warm you on a cold winter night.
My mamma’s broth is so damn good it should be patented. She mostly makes it in the winter. She always makes enough to last a couple of days, and in that time it is devoured with delight. There are a few dishes for which my mom’s hands have a magical touch. Her Dolma, her Vindaloo, Coffee cake and Macaron are my favorites, but her Abgoosht is out of control. She was 22 when this photo was taken. She had just gotten engaged to my father. She has that soft, content look on her face and she probably hadn’t learned to make Abgoosht just yet.
There is no doubt that bone marrow has a very distinct taste and texture, you either love it or hate it. I love it so much that I almost fainted from bliss when I saw this photo of my imaginary husband Anthony Bourdain with only a bone in his hand. The photo is from the book My Last Supper and is his homage to bone marrow, for which I graciously thank him for it every time I bite down on a piece of one. Bone marrow is usually cooked by braising it, such as with Osso Bucco (Italian), roasting it like Os a Moelle (French), or slow cooking it like Abgoosht (Persian). Ab in Farsi means water, in this case stew, and Ghoosht is in reference to the type of stew, in this case beef.
My favorite place to get bone marrow in Los Angeles outside of my mom’s kitchen is at Mario Batalli and Nancy Silverton’s, Pizzeria Mozza. Every few months my friend James and I have “Bone Marrow Dates.” We get together on a Sunday afternoon, get toasted on Perseco and eat bone after bone, topped with sea salt, roasted garlic and parsley leaves. James is fabulous. He’s an accomplished celebrity photographer I met a couple years ago while eating bone marrow at Mozza. We bonded over the marrow, and when we get together he tells me his juicy celeb stories, as we both drool over the juicy bone marrows on our table. I just made Abgousht for the first time a few days ago. My mom, Arax instructed me step by step and I followed. The smell of the broth slowly crept into the kitchen and I couldn’t help but peek in over and over again and get an Abgousht facial as the steam rose to my face. In the process of learning to make this stew, I also decided to properly learn to make roasted bone marrow. For inspiration I drew from Mr. Batalli, with his jolly belly and orange Crocs. I bought a couple of shanks, roasted them in the oven, and then I carefully slid them onto a toasted baguette and topped it with parsley, Fleur de Sel and lemon juice. It provided the perfect excuse to bust out the white truffle oil. Yes, I topped my fatty bone marrow with the truffle oil, and it was superb and worth every drop.
Being referred to as pathological that evening tickled my own bones a bit. It got me thinking that there is a very primal aspect to sucking marrow out of a bone. It is something many of us have done since childhood without giving it a second thought. In the chapter “What I Lived For,” in “Walden”, Thoreau explains his decision to move to Walden Woods. In the book he says, “I went into the woods because I wanted to live deliberately. I wanted to live deep and suck out all the marrow of life . . . to put to rout all that was not life; and not, when I came to die, discover that I had not lived.” I can’t think of a more perfect way to describe not just the importance of living life to the fullest, but living life in a truly conscious fashion. For me this includes eating all the bone marrow that life has to offer and maybe even looking within when I do eat it. Looking back, in retrospect maybe the scientist was right; eating bone marrow is like taking in parts of our own selves. But I prefer Thoreau’s take on it. In case you’re wondering what happened with Mr. Pathologist and I, we eventually went our separate ways. Besides, I couldn’t see myself dating a man who dated a woman that he thought was a pathological eater.
Dried limes can be found in most Middle Eastern stores or here. Dried savory leaves can be found in the spice section of most supermarkets or here.
Arax’s Abgoosht
Yield 4-6 servings
2 – 3 beef shanks with bone marrow attached
6 – 8 cups of water
1 cup garbanzo & white beans (mixed)
3 – 4 Limoo Amani (Dried Limes)
3 tomatoes skin removed, chopped small dice
1 onion, chopped medium dice
3 garlic cloves, chopped small dice
2 ½ tsp savory leaves (Dried)
5 cardamom pods
5 bay leaves
2 tsp turmeric
2 tsp curry powder
2 tsp hot pepper paste
2 tsp kosher salt
2 potatoes chopped medium dice
1 lemon
1 Lavash or Pita bread
- Place shanks in a large pot with 6 cups of with water and bring to boil. Skim the froth as it forms.
- Add the next 12 items, cover and cook on medium heat for 2-2 ½ hours until meat is tender. Add more water if you would like to have more broth.
- Add the potatoes and lemon juice, cook on medium heat for 20 minutes.
Serve with lavash, break lavash or pita into small pieces, add to the stew and enjoy.
Roasted Bone Marrow
Yield 4 servings
4 Beef shanks with Bone Marrow
3 tsp parsley, whole leaves
Fleur De Sel or course Sea salt
1 lemon, juiced
1 baguette French, sliced, toasted
- Preheat oven to 425 degrees, cover a large sheet pan with foil and cook marrow for 12-15 minutes, until marrow bubbles but not spilled over.
- With a thin knife, slowly carve out marrow from the bone and slide onto toasted bread, top with salt, parsley leaves and lemon juice.


















